There are no choices in life?

Anything that doesn't quite fit in elsewhere...
Post Reply
User avatar
Ozzie guy
Posts: 487
Joined: Sun May 16, 2021 4:40 pm

There are no choices in life?

Post by Ozzie guy »

If you accept the premise our brain is basically a computer doing what it thinks is best I don't think choice exists.
Choice would be more like an illusion when you reflect on memories and try to improve your rate of learning by thinking "what would happen if I did X instead of Y"
User avatar
erowind
Posts: 548
Joined: Mon May 17, 2021 5:42 am

Re: There are no choices in life?

Post by erowind »

I tried to write a thing but I'm too tired to write it properly. For the sake of providing information though you might find compatibilism a useful metaphysical school to read about. Compatibilists accept free will and determinism and view them both as mutually compatible without logical inconsistency.

https://plato.stanford.edu/entries/comp ... FreeDoOthe

I used to be a hard-deternimist myself and recently over the past two years softened my view into soft-determinism. There is near consensus between compatibilists and metaphysical libertarians that humans have free will, where libertarian here means accepting free will and rejecting determinism. Only around 12% of philosophers reject free will outright.

https://survey2020.philpeople.org/survey/results/4838

Also my intention with posting philosopher survey results is not to appeal to authority, there are cases, like the trolly problem for example, where I don't agree with consensus or even outright reject the question entirely. I'm posting this because it's useful for understanding a given question and the discussion around it to understand how contemporary philosophy views the question and look into the history of how a near consensus has formed.
Post Reply